The Puritan Threat
This section explains the Puritan threat to Elizabeth I and a timeline of the Key Puritan Challenges. Puritans were a group of devout Protestants who sought to "purify" the Church of England by removing any remaining Catholic elements. Their strict religious beliefs contrasted with Elizabeth I’s more moderate approach to Protestantism, as established in her Religious Settlement of 1559. The Settlement aimed to unify the nation by creating a Protestant Church that retained some Catholic traditions, but this compromise failed to satisfy the Puritans.
While the Puritans posed a significant ideological challenge to Elizabeth’s authority, they did not typically resort to rebellion or conspiracies. Instead, they sought to influence religious reform through Parliament and the Church. Despite this, Elizabeth viewed them as a threat to her power and worked to suppress their efforts.
The Nature of the Puritan Threat
Who Were the Puritans?
- Puritans were strict Protestants who wanted a "purer" form of worship, free from any Catholic practices.
- Many fled England during the reign of the Catholic Mary I but returned after Elizabeth’s accession in 1558, expecting more radical Protestant reforms.
Puritan Concerns with the Religious Settlement
- The Religious Settlement declared England officially Protestant but retained elements of Catholic tradition, such as clergy vestments and certain prayers.
- While many Puritans initially accepted the Settlement, they quickly began campaigns to make the Church more Protestant, focusing on Parliament and local prayer practices.
Puritan Influence in Elizabeth’s Court
- Some of Elizabeth’s key advisers, including Robert Dudley, Earl of Leicester, and Sir Francis Walsingham, were sympathetic to Puritan ideas.
- These figures attempted to persuade Elizabeth to take harsher actions against Catholics and adopt stricter Protestant policies.
Key Puritan Challenges
| Date | Puritan Challenge | Elizabeth’s Response |
|---|---|---|
| 1571 | Walter Strickland and the Vestarian Controversy Walter Strickland, a Puritan MP, proposed reforms to Elizabeth’s new Prayer Book and called for the banning of clergy vestments. | Elizabeth shut down Parliament to silence Strickland, ensuring his ideas could not gain traction or be debated. |
| 1575-1583 | Prophesyings Puritan clergy organised informal prayer meetings called "prophesyings," which deviated from Elizabeth’s prescribed practices. These meetings encouraged free-form prayer and discussion. | Elizabeth ordered Archbishop of Canterbury Edmund Grindal to suppress these meetings. When Grindal refused, she suspended him and expelled 200 Puritan priests. Grindal eventually apologised and was reinstated. |
| 1583 | John Stubbs’ Pamphlet John Stubbs, a Puritan, published a pamphlet criticising Elizabeth’s marriage negotiations with the Catholic French king’s brother. | Stubbs was arrested and sentenced to have his right hand cut off for stirring up dissent. This served as a stark warning to others who might challenge Elizabeth’s policies or authority. |
How Much of a Threat Were the Puritans?
While the Puritans posed an ideological challenge to Elizabeth’s authority, they were less of a threat compared to Catholics, who were more likely to engage in plots to overthrow her. Puritan efforts were mostly confined to Parliament and the Church rather than outright rebellion.
Reasons Puritans Were Seen as Less Threatening:
- They did not typically conspire to destabilise the monarchy or overthrow Elizabeth.
- Many Puritans were part of Elizabeth’s trusted Privy Council or Parliament, working within the system rather than against it.
Why Elizabeth Still Considered Them a Threat:
- Puritan efforts to alter the Religious Settlement were a direct challenge to her authority as Supreme Governor of the Church.
- Their campaigns disrupted religious unity and could potentially undermine the stability of her reign.
Decline of the Puritan Movement
Elizabeth’s firm resistance to Puritan demands ensured that their influence waned over time.
- By the 1590s, many Puritan leaders had passed away, and the movement lacked strong leadership.
- The majority of the population came to accept the Church of England as the national Church.
Conclusion
Although the Puritans sought significant reforms to Elizabeth’s religious policies, they were largely unsuccessful in their efforts. Elizabeth’s ability to suppress their campaigns and maintain her authority ensured the Religious Settlement remained intact, solidifying Protestantism in England while avoiding the extreme measures the Puritans desired. Their failure to gain widespread support meant that by the end of Elizabeth’s reign, they no longer posed a significant threat.
Category
